Persistent deficiencies in the measurement and reporting of tobacco use in contemporary genitourinary oncology clinical trials Review


Authors: Zhao, C.; Myrie, A.; Feuer, Z.; Roberts, T.; Sherman, S. E.; Bjurlin, M. A.; Matulewicz, R. S.
Review Title: Persistent deficiencies in the measurement and reporting of tobacco use in contemporary genitourinary oncology clinical trials
Abstract: Smoking is a causal or contributory factor for nearly all genitourinary cancers and exerts significant influence on treatment, quality of life, and survival outcomes. In order to understand the influence smoking has on the outcomes of contemporary therapies, pertinent smoking-related data must be systematically collected and report. We sought to determine how often and how rigorously smoking status is collected and reported in publications of clinical trials in genitourinary cancers by conducting a systematic review. Our initial search yielded 622 articles, 354 of which met criteria. The vast majority of included studies (91.8%) did not report any details about trial participants’ smoking status. When included, 96.3% of studies reported baseline status qualitatively. No studies used a validated measurement instrument or reported change in participants’ smoking status over the study period. Absence of the collection and reporting of smoking-related data precludes further study of how smoking impacts outcomes and highlights an important deficiency in GU oncology clinical trial design. © 2021 Elsevier Ltd
Keywords: neoplasm; neoplasms; quality of life; smoking; publication; cancer research; urogenital tract cancer; prostate cancer; systematic review; kidney cancer; epidemiology; transitional cell carcinoma; qualitative research; tobacco use; clinical trial (topic); study design; adverse event; humans; human; article; smoking prevention; people by smoking status
Journal Title: Cancer Epidemiology
Volume: 78
ISSN: 1877-7821
Publisher: Elsevier Inc.  
Date Published: 2022-06-01
Start Page: 102022
Language: English
DOI: 10.1016/j.canep.2021.102022
PUBMED: 34670728
PROVIDER: scopus
DOI/URL:
Notes: Article -- Export Date: 1 August 2022 -- Source: Scopus
Altmetric
Citation Impact
BMJ Impact Analytics
MSK Authors